Umpire / Dispute Resolution
Neutral Guidance for Fair Outcomes
When two parties cannot agree on a property damage value, our certified umpires provide impartial resolution that saves time, money, and relationships.
When is An Appraisal Panel Resolution Needed?
If the two appraisers are unable to reach an agreement, a neutral umpire is appointed. Together, the property owner’s appraiser, the insurance carrier’s appraiser, and the umpire make up the appraisal panel. All communication and correspondence during the process must include all three panel members. If discussions occur outside this format, the award could be invalidated due to improper (ex parte) communication.
The umpire’s role is to make a final determination on the scope and value of the damages. To finalize the appraisal, at least two of the three panel members must sign the award, making it binding on both the policyholder and the insurance company. The cost of the umpire’s fee is shared equally between both parties.
Our Role
- Independent Evaluation – Review conflicting estimates, documents, and evidence.
- Balanced Decision-Making – Determine a fair settlement figure when appraisers disagree.
- Documentation – Provide written determinations that both sides can trust.
- Efficiency – Resolve disputes without costly litigation or prolonged stalemates.
Benefits of Our Approach
- Avoid unnecessary lawsuits.
- Preserves business and client relationships.
- Ensures all parties have confidence in the process.
- Moves claims forward quickly.
Why Choose RRT Consulting
We provide credible, court-ready testimony backed by deep industry expertise and proven field experience.
FAQs
Q: What qualifications do your umpires have?
A: Our umpires are experienced claims professionals with construction and legal expertise, certified in dispute resolution.
Q: How binding are your determinations?
A: In most appraisal clauses, the umpire’s decision becomes binding once agreed to by one of the two appraisers.
Q: How quickly can disputes be resolved?
A: Many cases are resolved in weeks, far faster than traditional litigation.
Engage a Neutral Umpire Now
Check Out All Our Services
Inspections / Estimates
We prepare fair and accurate property inspections and comparative estimates for disputes over property scope and damage.
Expert Witness & Deposition
Our Florida-licensed general contractors bring proven expertise, testifying in property damage and scope disputes.
Peer Reviews (Written & Oral)
We conduct comprehensive reviews of damage estimates to ensure accuracy in scope, pricing, and settlement value.
Policy Appraisal Services
Our consultants represent both insurers and policyholders with extensive experience in policy appraisal proceedings.
Umpire Services & Dispute Resolution
When appraisal stalls, our experts serve as neutral umpires, resolving differences and guiding fair settlement outcomes.